Monday, May 23, 2016

A Reflection on Denver's First Sikh Parade



**UPDATE**: First of all, I would like to thank all the support on this blog. I know this has been receiving attention, so I would like to state for the fact that I welcome any discussion, that is the Gurmat way. I will not delete any comments.

Colorado's 1st Parade Celebration of Sikhs

On 05/22/16, history was made for the growing population of Sikhs in the state of Colorado. The first Nagar Keertan, or Sikh parade, took place at East High school in Denver. Over 1,500 people attended the event, whether it be as spectators, or parade participants. 


I remember attending my first Nagar Keertan in Toronto back in 2008, so obviously, this event became somewhat nostalgic. It was the first step for Sikhs in Colorado to spread awareness and education about Sikhism. Growing up in Colorado my whole life, I have seen the transformation of the Sikh- American community and my generation of millennials becoming more involved with the unique plight of Sikhs in a changing post- 9/11 America.  Serene Singh and I just co-founded the first Sikh Student Association in Colorado, located at CU Boulder. Sikhs within Colorado are heavily concentrated in the cities of  Denver, Colorado Springs, Boulder, and Castle Rock. Being the first Sikh parade to take place within all of Colorado, all of these communities were invited to perform sewa (commmunity service) and participate in activities. I live Colorado Springs & attend school in Boulder, so I was ecstatic to see how this event in Denver would transcend into those communities I am a part of. After helping organize both SALDEF's Langar on the Hills, an event focused on garnering the attention of public officials in DC through the concept of Langar, I was eager to bring those skills to this.  

During the day, I mainly focused my time talking to the media, non-Sikhs who attended the event, and giving a brief speech about SALDEF, an organization who has given me the tools and resources to Sikh Youth from all around the country to speak their truth.  (Here is the Denver Post article)

Pictured with SSA Youth President: Serene Singh
I absolutely adored every aspect of the day, but what I enjoyed the most was talking to the non-Sikh community who showered us with support. Speaking as someone who was bullied in school, and now advocate for change, I felt inspired that we, as Sikhs, could count on our neighbors. Seeing Americans sitting on their porches waving, cheering, sometimes even walking among us, I felt the change being made. Even changing one person's perception of my community meant one more person knowing that we exist, we are real, and that we are Americans.  

I do think it is important to critically evaluate events like this, because there is always room for improvement. Especially with a young Sikh community in America, striving for accuracy in what we project outwards should be given priority. After the event took place, I sat down and began to think of all the longing concerns I had and what they could have stemmed from. I am saying this with all the genuineness in my heart- these are just my suggestions in making this event's message clear, and not to hurt anyone, and especially not the sewa done. If there is one thing I have learned from leadership, it is about speaking with honesty and courage, despite what the consequences might be.  My faith has also taught me to speak with josh, himmat, and also in chardi kala. 

  1. Platform for ALL voices: The SSA President and I were scheduled to give speeches representing
    SALDEF Presentation
    SSA @ CU Boulder and SALDEF, and also perform keertan. However, everything but my speech was cut the day before. To make matters more disheartening, practically 90% of the speeches/keertan programs that took place at the event were by males. The individuals that were representing Sikh Youth in Colorado, the female perspective, the minority perspective, were being cut. Maybe it is only coincidence, but mine was the only one that kept getting pushed back ( located at 18:30) and further back due to people running over-time on their speeches/keertan. Unfortunately, every time I would go sit next to the podium amongst other men waiting for my turn, I would always be the only one asked to move. I later realized all video cameras that were pointing at the podium would only show men, and no one was being asked to move otherwise. Every time a man wanted to sing or say a few words, I would always be the one having to move back and wait for them to finish. By the time I was given the chance to speak on behalf of SALDEF, I was being told aggressively I could only speak for 1 minute, and the entire time I was speaking, men were behind me tapping me on the back, indicating for me to finish. Despite having a powerpoint prepared detailing my work as a Sikh Youth, I could barely give justice to what it deserved. 
Now, I am not complaining about the time given to me. I understand large scale events often have a lot of time constraints. But what did concern me was I was the only one who was asked to keep waiting for my speech and those who were suppose to go after me, were being switched around and also weren't being rushed. I would have much preferred to be told there would be no time for me to speak, then having to constantly be told to move away from the cameras multiple times while waiting my turn.
  1. Female Representation ( or lack there-of): I have always struggled with the lack of female representation in gurudwara politics, and sometimes attributed that to females just not wanting to come forward. But upon further evaluation, I noticed a couple of things. All 10 of the Panj Pyaare, were male. All volunteers wearing the volunteer badges, were male. All speakers on behalf of the gurudwara, were male. Sewadaars in the diwaan hall doing guru ka seva, all male. Granted, I am sure there were females who were in roles, but my worry is it wasn't a proportional amount to the amount of females in our community. In fact, a non-Sikh asked me why no females were wearing sashes, and I didn't have a good enough answer to give back.  On one hand, we are telling media about equality of the sexes, holding banners with quotes from SGGS about female empowerment, and yet, not making it a point to showcase females in the same way as males. If we want to practice what we preach about equality, we need to make it a point to bring women forwards, and not push them behind. Even if females are not in political positions in our gurudwaras, I do think it is the job of the sangat to make sure roles are accessible to all. Granted, women were doing sewa before the event in large ways. My hope is in the future, American spectators at the event can see this in full force the day of. Sikhism is beautiful with it's pioneering movement to equate the sexes and we should symbolically demonstrate that, as a community, in all aspects.
  2. Engaging with our American neighbors: I noticed as the event went on how confused non-Sikhs were walking in. I saw them not wanting to enter the diwaan hall for fear they were not allowed, what protocol was, or looking for a place to pay for langar. I saw tables set up everywhere asking for monetary donations, but no one willing to answer questions our American community had about who we are. So I quickly took the liberty in filling that void.
    At the Parade
    Although it became the most fruitful part of my time at the Nagar Keertan, I do think this is an excellent platform to spread awareness and actually engage correctly  in one on one conversations with people who show a genuine interest in getting to know who we are. In the future, perhaps these keertans can distribute fliers and other materials about Sikhs while walking in the parade. I think living in America at a time when people solve their anger with guns, and politicians rhetoric is often hate-filled, education about our faith is key to making us known. 
  3. Gurudwara Politics: Furthermore, rules were being passed by leaders that were meant to uplift only some. As a co-founder of SSA, that too the only SSA in Colorado, I was so excited for our organization to be recognized at the parade and bring the student voice to the table. However, at the event, we were told banners were not allowed. Now, that is a completely understandable rule to make, no denying that. But certain organizations were being promoted during the parade, while all others are "banned." Up until the day of the event, it was being promoted as a joint Sikh parade on behalf of all Sikhs in Colorado and neighboring states. However, even when police commissioners from Colorado Springs were wanting time to speak at the event, they were being told there was "no time." We were honoring candidates for public office, who have yet not made any tangible change for Sikhs in Colorado, but didn't have time to honor those on the ground making America a bit safer. Especially with how recently Oak Creek happened and all the shootings happening in our state, I do think the Police departments play a tremendous role in keeping our community safe. Now, I know this is a touchy issue, because our gurudwaras are very centered over politics. Questions like "who can make us earn the most money," and "which person can shout the loudest in a room," is often what I hear in meetings. I think we have lost sight as a community what the meaning of sangat is. Yes, maybe a sangat being given power back isn't the most structured, and maybe it isn't the most easy to handle. But I honestly believe the sangat is what makes our community unite despite internal divides. Financial status, gender identity, education status, age, caste, creed, color, whatever it might, don't belong in gurudwaras. We, as a Sikh community, should strive to be better than that, and I know we can.


    This was by no means an attack on an event, just a critical reflection on what we can do in future years. Once again, I would like to stress I do appreciate the sewa put by everyone in making this event happen. Moving forwards, I think it would be great if the Sikh community, not just limited to Colorado, can take on these points as things to improve on in future years. Our youth need to be engaged, our females need to feel empowered, and our broader American community needs to feel welcomed. Only then, can Sikhs really leave a footprint in our American history.

In Chardi kala!
These views reflect nothing but my own. 



Update ( October 13th, 2016): Wow. It has been a couple of months since I published this blog and I am still amazed with the amount of attention it has received. I must say, during the first month of this being out, I was met with intense backlash, even from uncles I have grown up with my entire life. To put in perspective to those of you who might be reading this for the first time, here are some of the comments I received ( both verbally and written)...

  • "it's absurd and ridiculous to bring FEMALE ANGLE on this."
  • "This girl is crazy."
  • " Delete this blog. If you don't, you and your family would face severe consequences."
  • " You can only have this blog up on 1 condition... Send it to me so I can edit it and approve."
  • "The reason why you weren't given time to speak is because you didn't donate enough money to the event."
  • "Why on earth would the Denver Post quote 3 girls?"
  • "Women can NEVER become Panj Pyaare. That can just never happen."
The worst part? The list goes on.....

A couple of things I would like to say. The whole point of 'blogging' is for one to share their perspective, thoughts, and opinions. I welcome discussion, and I actually haven't deleted any comments to the blog because I think the Sikh community needs to have more open dialogue. All comments that have been deleted were as a result of the person who wrote them. My point is, I am a confident youth leader. What that means for me is I speak my mind unconditionally, and shouldn't have to send this blog to anyone for edits, or censorship.

More importantly, I was so disappointed at the amount of threats my family was receiving because of this blog. Granted, we might disagree on some of my ideas, but by no means should it open doors filled with hate and blanketed threats. The most interesting part about this whole experience was I wasn't confronted once face to face by anyone who had an issue with the blog. It would be circled around friend groups, which would then reach me.

Now I agree, I didn't donate enough money. I am a student, I don't have a job that pays enough for me to donate. But that should be okay. Never once did our Gurus discriminate someone on the basis of money, so why has the Sikh community started to today? To my knowledge, the SGGS doesn't equate money with spiritual power, so why use it as a criteria to distinguish if someone can speak at a Sikh event or not?

If me speaking my mind, encouraging other youth to do the same, and advocating for groups of marginalized Sikhs to have a bigger say in events is "crazy," then by all means deal me in.

 I think Steve Jobs put it best when he said, "Here's to the crazy ones, the misfits, the rebels, the troublemakers, the round pegs in the square holes... the ones who see things differently -- they're not fond of rules... You can quote them, disagree with them, glorify or vilify them, but the only thing you can't do is ignore them because they change things... they push the human race forward, and while some may see them as the crazy ones, we see genius, because the ones who are crazy enough to think that they can change the world, are the ones who do."


Slowly and surely though, I started to see a shift in the conversation to one more accepting of my thoughts. Organizations that were not even Sikh based, began to share my blog on their platforms. I was so blessed to have had SALDEF, an organization I have been with for the past 3 years have my back through everything. I had uncles from the area bring me on to other projects and have my voice in decisions. ( To read about the latest project I was asked to help out with, please visit here). But most importantly, I am glad to have had youth leaders in my life constantly encourage me to not delete this blog and continue to speak my truth.

At the last event I helped put on, where I gave a speech about the Sikh turban to more than 2,000 people, I realized what my blog has led me to. It led me to opportunities I would have never received had I not written it. Many individuals who were so against me in the beginning came and apologized to me at that event for the way they behaved. I was given time to speak my truth, whereas I was pushed away at the Nagar Keertan. I'm not saying this to say I am in the right. Granted, I make mistakes. But this blog sparked something in the community, and I think it transformed people to view events like this in a different light.

The history of Sikhism, alongside Gurbani, has often given me the inner strength and power to keep moving forward. That is what I am going to try to continue even today.

52 comments:

  1. Naureen, as a non-Sikh I so appreciate your comments. I also want to say, don't be discouraged - this is the first one and there are always kinks to be worked out. Your very honest look at what you would like to see done differently is going to be exactly what is needed to mature this wonderful outreach. Keep following your heart and passions - they will change our world.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mama Liz,

      You are so incredibly sweet and thank you for your kind words of encouragement. I promise to not be discouraged and this was really my way to get my sentiments out so my community can grow stronger in the future :)

      Delete
  2. Thank you for sharing your honest views. I think all Sikhs should read this becuz you bring up some very good points we should do as a faith. thx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your support! I do appreciate it!

      Delete
  3. Natureen, thanks so much for filling the voids and keeping the faith.You make some excellent point and the sikh faith needs forward thinking leaders like yourself. Keep up the good work

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your kind words and support. I really do appreciate it! :)

      Delete
  4. Very well written my little sister, I am proud of you. Yes I noticed these minor bumps on the road. I guess we need to address them before we start up again next year. Hopefully this will be a learning step for the future

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Harleen, thank you so much for your kind words and support. I agree- hopefully these issues can be fixed in future years so we can grow as a Sikh community in Colorado!

      Delete
  5. I am so proud of everything you have accomplished, not only for Colorado, but also for the U.S. Keep doing you, sister.I wish I could've been there! This is something I would take my children to. Thank you for empowering women everywhere. Who was it that said, be the change you want to see? Well that is you, and I will always be there to back it up! I should convince my seniors next year to have you speak at their graduation--if you aren't otherwise off saving the world ;-) one Nagar Keertan at a time!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello,
    With lot of respect I would like to tell something, people must take care of the fact that before they preach they should practice the same. One must look at your own mistakes before pointing it out at someone else. If someone has consumed the holy water, they should know that seva is not done for the sake of attention.
    People do seva from their heart, without looking for appreciation. It comes from within. What I would like to point out is that, the entire divan hall, floor and flower decorations , Langar seva, Prashad di seva, shoe di seva, Palki seva, organisation of Punj Pyare and many more things were done by the ladies. People must know all the facts before they can state it.
    Do they know, there was a adult sangat group from our Denver Gurughar who had to perform kirtan for 45mins, but due to shortage of time we had to completely cut it out. This is because we had to give time to those people who travelled all the way from Utah, California and New Mexico for this Nagar Kirtan. Being Sikhs of Denver, it was our responsibility to take care of such guests and appreciate their presence.
    Moreover, nagar kirtan organisation has been going on in the Gurudwara past 1 whole month. What we would like to know is that, how many times did these girls come and contribute. They haven't been there to see how everyone has worked so hard. By passing such comments they have hurt the sentiments of all those people who have worked hard, men or women.
    In Sikhism, we believe me in equality. All the people involved in making this nagar kirtan a success gave their heart and soul into it. Nobody was doing it to get exposure in any form of media.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Kanwal Uncle,

      Thank you for taking the time to respond to the post- the good thing is that we are communicating w/each other, and in this process, there are times we may not see eye to eye. That's also a part of our learning and how to make sure our next parade will be better.

      Let me reassess my post here again for your benefit. I never once meant to take away any respect for the sewadaars in planning for this event. Respectfully, half of my blog was saying the good that came out of this. I was just bringing up suggestions that we can do in the future to expand on this event. This is positive.

      I also do think sewa should not be quantifiable. I agree, sewa should be done through the heart, and no point in the post did I negate that. And because I believe sewa should be done by the heart, I do not want to take the time to tell and share with you the sewa I did. Sewa shouldn't seek attention and rewards, and that respectfully includes other people's approval about my sewa.

      After this blog was published, I was being told by unknown + unnamed leaders that because I didn't donate enough money, that I was less deserving of time to speak.

      It was not that I woke up day of the event and demanded to give a speech. Not at all. Frankly, I was told I would give a speech, and I was the only one to get pushed back over and over again, until the absolute last minute. Even then, I wasn't given respect during my speech, and this was not done to other speakers.

      You wrote earlier [now deleted], "In the near future, we would not want such people to be part of our activities." I think that is unfortunately the exact issue I am trying to point out in my blog. Exclusion isn't and shouldn't be a part of Sikhism, no matter if you may disagree with one another or not. Even in Gurbani does it teach that only through intellectual dialogue can we reach an understanding.

      When you keep referring to "these girls," you need to remember these girls are also a part of sangat and are proud to be part of this community. I try to practice what I preach, and if I did something that was against Sikhi, or downgrading someone, I would like to know. Again, let me emphasize I applaud those who worked so hard to arrange this parade.

      My suggestions, just like your critique above, is not intentionally meant to hurt people, but rather support everyone to make this event better.

      In Chardi Kala!

      Delete
    2. I deleted that reply, because I felt that the last lines which I wrote were harsh and wrong,and I appreciate that you spoke your mind so well, there are no hard feelings against you, we are all free to express our mind by writing and talking to each other . Rabb Rakha

      Delete
  8. I think we should only look at this as a very successful event and as always there is an opportunity to do something better next time. And of course event of this size means lot of seva by lot of people and there is no intention to undermine the effort or hurt any feelings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I completely agree with what you wrote. These are just a few of the suggestions I think all Nagar Keertans, not just the one in Colorado, can take on in the future in order to grow our community and what we stand for in the future.

      Delete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gur Fateh Auntie,

      As always, I appreciate your detailed comment. I would like to stress that I did mention in my blog above about females doing sewa for this event. I never once denied that, and that was not the point of my blog either. For me, speaking from a youth female to adult female, I would have liked to see females represented in the same way as males during the event. Having to answer to the non-Sikh community about the representation of females during the course of the day became a concern. Although I might have known females were part of the planning process, it wasn't evident to our American neighbors day of.

      I also want to say again for the fact that I am proud of this event, as I did mention that a few times in my blog. If there is something you found immature in my blog, I would like you to share it. I was just sharing my story and perspective, and this was not meant to put anyone down.

      This is just a blog to share my opinion and views on things. Just because one may not necessarily agree, it doesn't mean we should bring personal credentials into the mix. I haven't attacked anyone on a personal basis to the blog, because I do think Sikhs are better than that. Gurbani teaches us to not judge others, and I would really like this discussion to refrain from doing personal attacks.

      In Chardi kala,

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    4. Hi Aunty,

      I was at the event, as well. I must say I do not agree with you. There is no need to be taking what is being said as an attack and I would hope that with your experience in Sikhism, you would respect and appreciate those few youth in our community that are fighting for what they believe is right. At least, this is what I would hope to be one day for young girls especially in my gurdwara.

      No aunty jee...The Denver Post actually actively sought out Naureen, her sister, and Harmann, another Kaur. However, leaders in the gurdwara actually expressed their strong dissent for these three girls all being published in this article. How unfortunate. As a woman, I would hope you would prop and support these three girls for being so knowledgable and for wanting more from our community. Instead, you are here making unnecessary jabs and almost agreeing with the male leaders who did not approve of three girls all being featured in an article. This is upsetting for me to watch, aunty. With that, I thank the aunty's and even various uncles reading this post who stand with all the Kaur's who felt unequal. Hopefully Gurpreet Aunty will come to recognize this soon enough.

      I hope you would see this event as more than something of males vs females. Naureen's blog explicitly laid out how she could envision representation being stronger in the future. I understand you had a huge role in the event, and that means you have such a beautiful opportunity to support a fellow Kaur whom you should be proud of. Instead, you are choosing to use your leadership as a way to silence not just Naureen but all three of the girls in the article who are still hurt from the negative response of the gurdwara. These girls had to fight to be in this article, and it is saddening to see they have to fight for themselves even after the article has been published.

      Delete
    5. Gurbani - Are you not getting personal?

      Delete
    6. Thanks Gurbani for your words.

      I think the unfortunate reality of our Sikh structure all around the world really boils down to politics. There are a lot of decisions being made and answers being made that are without the knowledge of the sangat. A few times after this was published, I have received threats from Denver Gurudwara leadership to remove the article or face consequences. That not only is not very Sikhi, it stifles people from sharing their thoughts and concerns.

      And kindly Gurpreet Auntie, your comments were very personal, as I did not attack anyone in my blog nor did I ever attack you. My personal credentials can only back me up, and I will never feel ashamed of them despite what you might like me to think or believe.

      And yes, the struggle to even be in the Denver Post was a big one. It deeply saddens me that the sangat has been giving whiplash that three girls were quoted.

      It is important to remember there is always a bigger picture, and my blog was just simply stating ways to take a step back and look at it.

      Delete
  10. This was a first big event in Denver; I personally think that organizers did a very good job. It takes a lot of planning, hard work, funds, getting permits and implementing it. Based on what Naureen have accomplished so far... she should be aware of all this. I felt there is room of improvement and it will always be there even after 5 years as we will keep on raising our bar. I think it was job very done. We don't have to be disheartened and be thankful that Sangat took initiative to do this event for the first time in the history of Denver. It is time to be thankful as we can only grow from here.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello,

      First of all, thank you for your comment. I do agree with you that this is the first event to happen in Denver, and the first half of my blog is stating exactly what you just said.

      If your read my blog again, you will see that I am not making this into a personal attack, just offering some suggestions for not just Colorado, but ALL sikh Communities to think of in the future.

      I think improvement can be done in stages. I am not too sure how or why my personal credentials are of any concern, since this is just an opinion piece on what I saw at the event, alongside many others.

      Thanks!

      Delete
    2. Fateh,

      I think we are all saying the same thing. Naureen, as an advocate for Sikhs in America is stating that improvement is warranted. I could not agree more. Yes, even after 5 years we will still need change- but that is not the point. You are writing on behalf of anonymous user so I cannot say if you are aware of what is ACTUALLY being said in the article. I would ask that you humbly read the blog again, and perhaps you will see what the purpose is. In the future, please do not use someones credentials and their experience as an insult. It is a beautiful dynamic for our Colorado Sikhs to have a pioneer for change like Naureen.

      We are all thankful. However, it is equally important to be hopeful. Being willfully ignorant is not the answer so please refrain from putting on a label to alter the intention of this article.

      Thanks!

      Delete
  11. What a wonderful article Naureen with the detailed critics to share with anyone and all to share.

    This is exactly the way it should be.

    Just one question from my side here

    is there an official web site or designated channels one could express their opinions or the feedback because if there is none KUDDOS to you for doing this service to the entire community for bringing out the nitty gritty to improve upon the next time.

    My guess is its not the norms for the communities to share the critique this way?
    Reading all the above comments also brings out one more fact that here all the men are responding negatively? Is this also the norms? You did a wonderful job and your comments were an absolute positive feedback so keep up the good work. It will take a long time for the approval of it or perhaps they are missing the message entirely what you are portraying.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your kind words of support. I have noticed these sort of issues when it comes to politics in the gurudwara, but I have always felt response has been stifled. But writing this blog showed me that a large amount of the Sikh community faces the same issues, and it isn't often generation defined.

      I hope in the future these suggestions can be taken into account so all voices are represented, that is the Sikhi way. Hopefully the leaders won't take what I said offensively, since I am just voicing an opinion, and not spewing a hate filled attack.

      Delete
  12. naureen cute pictures here. So fancy dupatta. did you got that for the parade.
    most part I am baffled by these negative comments here trying to justify the blog so I must be missing something here. Your blog is beautifully written here with clear cut message how to improve on in the future. what I understand isn't this the message of being a SIKH to learn and improve upon so why this ruckus. My guess is the language barrier here because the beautifully message isn't coming across as also mentioned couple of times by others. this hullabaloo will stop with in days but your message will has already left a lasting impression as always with your blogs.
    proud of you for speaking your viewpoint.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Malika,

      Thank you for your kind words. Yes, the scarves were provided for the parade. Don't they look awesome?

      And to answer your question, I think it might be based on people skipping over the first half of my blog and just focusing on the bottom. Which does suck because I have to keep on explaining to read the whole post, but that is okay! Change is messy and heated sometimes, but that is what discussion is for.

      As always, I appreciate the support!

      Delete
  13. Hi naureen!
    You know wrote down the full post and computer dies what a bummer!!!
    the message I wrote you in private is here now for all to read.

    when already in bold why are all these questions about sevadars working hard is beyond me. this is from a non sikh point of view because how I read your article is a gem and the community should be proud to hear and spread the parade message clearly by such a talented trained youth, don't they?
    Naureen your work with the youth especially with and for the sikhs is commendable and don"t you let some group of organizers tell you otherwise. roadblocks will be there as with the private input and chain of praises is what you should built upon,. You have brought for all to read a beautifully written message to get better and should have be taken with that spirit only.
    like I wrote to you in my private messsage also reading this blog on another friend's wall that this keertan was not happening in any rural or downtrodden city in INDIA but happening in the state of CO and for people to read this aggressively here shows their mentality nothing better. In the western world this is how the youth is taught to communicate and not shut down any or all critic.

    Comments like these give a clear picture the colorado sikhs have a lot of growing to do.
    Your master-piece is there for all to see and read and job well done!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Sonali,

      Thank you for your kind words. As always, I appreciate the support! I have received a lot of private messages from other people at the event, and just Sikhs in general, so reading material like this is most appreciated.

      I promise not to lose courage, especially when it comes to speaking my mind :)

      Delete
  14. Couple things that I think are pertinent to the discussion. First of all the sikh parade was not a representation of gender. This wasn't about Kaurs or Singhs (anyone in particular). This was about sikhi. The point that people get racially profiled because of color or gender was not the focus of this parade. Hate crimes/violence against Sikhs was the focus. Spreading awareness about Sikhi in general was the focus. Also we all have sons/daughters. It's quite obvious that sikh boys face bullying in school and are also profiled as terrorists based on turban (which is particular to sikhi unlike being brown which a lot of races possess) and beard. Most of these things apply primarily to sikh men/boys. Most of the hate crimes in past have been targeted at sikh men, I have never heard about a similar crime against a female. These points besides, none of these things are applicable to what the goal of this parade was. However one can always highlight the negative points of such an effort, and ignore the positive aspects of this parade.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Gurpreet Auntie,

      Thanks for your comment. First of all, if you are going to keep bringing up my credentials, I think I should stay most of the work I do on behalf of the Sikh community revolves around bullying and hate crimes. Saying that this is a male issue is not only highly inaccurate, it is problematic. I was bullied because of my faith and long hair, so yes, females do face bullying/crimes, even if it is not in the scale as males. If you don't want to take my word for it, you might want to re-read the Denver post article in which another female talked about being bullied as well. Just because some people might have never heard of it or have had daughters that faced it, doesn't mean it isn't credible or valid.

      But that is besides the point. Half of my blog was the positive aspects of the parade, which you perhaps might have glanced over.

      And yes, the parade was a representation of gender because in case you might have forgotten, most of the quotes that were printed on banners were about gender, and equality was a huge focus of the parade. That is exactly what I talked about in my blog as well. If you want to bring in Sikhi, that is exactly what I am talking about. I am not bringing in Punjabi culture, or anything else, I am bringing in gurbani. I am not trying to make this into a males vs females debate. This is about equating the sexes and that accessibility is provided to both. That's all.

      Delete
    2. You can't assume everyone posting as anonymous is your Gurpreet Auntie

      Delete
    3. If you have something to say, you might as well remove yourself as being "anonymous." Be proud of what you write and stand by your words.

      Btwwwwww, Gurpreet totally has been commenting all day and switching accounts, so i dont blame nareen for her post.

      good job naureen. keep up the good work

      Delete
    4. Thanks Laura,

      If you would like to have a more deeper discussion, I am always welcome to do so. As I said in my blog, I wasn't expecting rainbows after I published this. I wanted this to be an honest conversation, but that becomes hard when I am talking to multiple anonymouses on this who don't want their name to be shared, or having their name shared and then deleting comments.

      No harm done!

      Delete
  15. With lot of respect I would like to tell something, people must take care of the fact that before they preach they should practice the same. One must look at your own mistakes before pointing it out at someone else. If someone has consumed the holy water, they should know that seva is not done for the sake of attention.



    Hello to you all

    My reply is first to this gentleman for his comment.

    He is not clear about what facts is he talking about?
    What sermons are given anywhere in this blog?
    please clarify this statement here because its vague and rude to say the least.

    about the practice part isn't what all Sikhs should be doing to spread the message across. Being a Sikh means doing sewa so where are his comments and defining sewa coming from? Can this writer clarify himself what the heck is he trying to say here.


    Now for Naureen's message as always I am her follower on all her posts and blogs and another outstanding and clear message from her. There are not two perspectives here they are negative and positive. You are all in the lala land defining sikhi this narrow way. Sikhi is all about the universal message and with her blog Naureen is doing that job to the non sikhs by letting them know before they write later that parade was wonderful,all sewadaars were awesome and great but there is room for improvements. Isn't that the video also was about to improve on the mistakes? So why not let a youth candidate cleary define that message rather than controlling her viewpoint.
    The Sikh community as a general need to point per point read her article,understand the wording this young girl has written and then wisely and patiently ask her any grey areas rather than without reading the article in its entirety come with their ridiculous comments.
    naureen we need the youth voice in the white house and everywhere to bring the ignored and the suppressed communities this exact way. Thanks for this uplifting and well written blog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Sajini,

      First of all, I would like to sincerely thank you for staying updated on my blog, and all my posts. That is not only very kind of you, it makes me feel inspired that these words I am writing on a blog that really started off as a way to spread events, is now creating dialogue and change.

      I really think that is where the beauty of this blog lies in- it's ability to bring people outside of a gurudwara setting and discuss and share their opinions. I have primarily written my blog based on my experience as a Sikh not only at this parade, but years of being part of the sangat in Colorado.

      Once again, thank you for your kind words of support!

      Delete
  16. Hello Naureen Beta Ji,
    I have read your blog thoroughly. The Colorado community has worked hard for our first Nagar Kirtan. I would like to explain the reality of this event. I have worked closely with the sevadars and have noticed how difficult everything was. Multiple trips were made to California to observe the Nagar Kirtans there and to bring this event to success, the Colorado Community worked day and night. Since this was our very first Nagar Kirtan, mistakes were bound to happen.
    Kirtan was to be done by the adults within the time frame. Within that time frame, the Colorado sangat wanted to give respect to the non Colorado residents by prioritizing their Kirtan. Many of the Colorado sangat memebers decided that they would rather let guests do Kirtan. After all, we were to respect all of those people who traveled from other states to join us for the event. We were also supposed to stay on schedule. Even with the shortage of time, we honored you and gave you a few minutes to talk about Sikhism. We also had to honor the Colorado officers within the time frame. The Nagar Kirtan was supposed to start at 1:30, but we were already running late. We were also paying for 30 officers from 1:30 to 4:00 to escort us. The Nagar Kirtan was to be off the streets by 4:00.
    The media was controlled by the youth, many of whom were women. No one intentionally disregarded women in this event. Females were also given the same chances as men. Simran Kaur was actually one of the panj pyare, leading the group from the start to finish. More than 30 women participated in the seva of preparing for the Nagar Kirtan. The Palaki Sahib, diwan hall, and the float were decorated by women. Groups of women were leading in the langar seva. Ladies also held the large flags during the Nagar Kirtan.
    All people who were not familiarized with Sikhism were welcomed with open arms. Sangat was doing a great job of informing the people and the feedback was great.. I do not believe our community scared any other ethnicity. In fact, they were all enjoying the Nagar Kirtan. I have witnessed this all.
    The banners did not represent any other organization. Banners were to be only strictly about gurbani and its message.
    We should not hurt the feelings of the Colorado Sikh Sangat's feelings because everyone put in a lot of effort hoping everyone would enjoy this precious event. Next year we can address the concerns you had with the Nagar Kirtan, and hopefully plan it better.
    "If one changes the way one looks at things, the things one looks at change" - Dr. Wayne Dyer

    Bhul Chuk Maaf Karne


    Sincerely,
    Jessie Singh

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Jessie,

      I would first like to thank you for your comment and taking the time to respond to my blog in a way that wasn't threatening or demeaning, even if we may disagree. These past few days have been frustrating for me to see the leadership of the parade respond to this blog with threats, hate, and anger- which was not the purpose of this blog. I do appreciate the work all the sewadaars put into this event, please don't get me wrong- I never once meant to take away from that. These were just a couple of suggestions we should try to implement, not just in Colorado, but as a broader Sikh community.

      I actually think we are agreeing on many of the same things, which I did explicitly state in my blog. There are a few things I would like to respectfully disagree with you though.

      I never once complained about not performing keertan at this event. In fact, I did state in my blog that I do understand time constraints with large events like this. If it was the decision to focus on those who traveled far for this, I think it should have been communicated better with the sangat. But regardless, that wasn't the case. I did have to travel 90 miles for this, but unfortunately, most of the time for kids was given to those from the Denver sangat. In fact, no one from my local gurudwara was the opportunity to do keertan, whereas at least 7-8 youth from Denver did. If giving respect to those who traveled far for this event, I would have been in that category since I did have to travel farther than my backyard.

      But, I think it is also important for me to say that I am not complaining about the time of the speech. I do want to clarify I was not given "a few minutes," I was barely given even 1 minute. I didn't bring this up in the blog, but since you are bringing it up now, I would like to explain the reality of my situation.

      I sat down in the diwaan hall for 3 hours, and saw time after time people going over-time on their speeches, or leaders even confused as to what some of the speeches were about. However, no one was being disrespectful about it, tapping them on the back to finish, yelling at them to take the podium. I was given the time of 11:50, and also told pretty aggressively that if I was not there at that time, I would not be able to speak. The other Sikh male youth who was suppose to go after me was just simply told to be there on time. I was so scared, I got there 15 minutes early so I wouldn't be cut. Even after the Sikh male youth went, I kept waiting and waiting and every time I would be called to go next and sit next to the podium, I would be the only one kicked out, even if I was sitting right next to someone else. Not only that, there were a few times, uncles would go up to the organizers and say they wanted to go next, and I had to keep waiting. By the time I was finally going to speak, the panj pyaare entered the diwaan hall and it became chaotic with multiple things happening. I didn't write this in my blog, but I was being yelled at to go speak quickly, and that things were running late. I understand that, but if that was the case, someone should have been timing ALL speeches, and keertans, and not blame the last person who was invited to speak on behalf of an organization. Even more frustratingly, men were constantly putting their hands on my lower back while giving the speech, rather than my shoulders or the podium itself. I don't consider that "honoring" me to give a speech, when I had to fight for more than 1 hour to get in a few words, and had to deal with some pretty sexist acts. I was the only one to keep getting pushed back and back during the entire event, which I think begs some questions.

      Delete
    2. As for women, I did say in my blog that I did recognize women being a part of sewa process. What my argument is that on the day-of, the media and our American neighbors could not see that and I couldn't answer those questions as to why that was. We can't say as a community, that because one women was on stage, we filled a void. I think that leads us down a slippery slope with equality. My argument was that it should be proportional to the amount of females in our gurudwara.

      As for media, another female Sikh youth and I having to fight, not being given the opportunity, to give speeches. In fact every time we did, we were be rudely interrupted by male members.

      Also, the sewa I took on at this event was engaging with our neighbors about Sikhism. In fact, only a select few were the only ones doing this at the event that by the end of it, people were emailing us about getting to know more about Sikhism. The only thing I am stating in my blog is if those select few weren't there, people would have left the event feeling confused with questions unanswered. I am just suggesting there should be a team designated for this since I think it is one of the most important aspect's of the parade.

      And I have to also respectfully disagree with you about the banners. If a Sikh Student Association doesn't promote Sikhi or it's message, than I don't know what does. This wasn't a church or an outside group, this was an association ( also the first one in CO), made by Sikh Youth, to talk about Sikhism so our community faces less discrimination, bullying and hate crimes in society. Not only that, people designated on behalf of organizers aggressively came to the table and ripped the banner off in front of media. I think that is where the problem lies. And also, Colorado Singh Sabha was represented at the parade on a float, whereas our gurudwara in Springs was told we can't have anything. My blog was just pointing out this slippery slope of rules.


      Yes, if my blog was making personal attacks and saying that this parade was awful ( WHICH IT WASN'T), I would be the first to apologize. But that's not the case. All I am asking is us to consider these suggestions. But frankly, with the amount of threats I have received from the leadership, also being told that because I didn't donate enough money I wasn't given enough time to speak, and being later told that leaders were upset that 3 girls were quoted in the Denver Post, it makes me question the premise and integrity of what happened.

      And there is no need to apologize for your post, I wanted this blog to be a deeper discussion. Gurbani teaches us to speak your mind and use of intellect to reach middle ground.

      ਜਿਉ ਬੋਲਾਏ ਤਿਉ ਬੋਲੀਐ ਜਾ ਆਪਿ ਬੁਲਾਏ ਸੋਇ ॥
      I speak just as He makes me speak, when He Himself makes me speak.

      Delete
  17. I think the intention of the blog has been lost here and we need more young Sikhs like Naureen who are not afraid to reflect on ourselves critically. If we can't even accept that there is a room for improvement, we can't improve anything. Perception is reality and even though everyone did put their best efforts to make this event successful, if something was lost in the perception to the outside world, it becomes our duty to create the opportunity for improvement in that area next time. It takes courage to see our own shortcomings but that is the only way to better us. Naureen's blog is very well written and it has praise for this tremendous event and effort while reflecting at the opportunities for next time.

    Inderpal Singh Chopra

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Inderpal Uncle,

      First of all, I would like to sincerely thank you for your kind words of support and encouragement. It really does mean a lot to have support, especially from male members of my sangat, for the issues I was talking about. I couldn't agree with you anymore when it comes to the message about improving our event, not only for our American neighbors, but even growing spiritually as a community.

      Once again, I can't thank you enough for your comment. It really does inspire me to keep speaking my mind in a way that will hopefully help benefit our community!

      Delete
    2. Joginder Pal SinghMay 26, 2016 at 1:02 PM

      Naureen beta,

      The post and the vms put above its all self explanatory that the important message for the media and for all CO boys and girls was rushed and expedited for some reasons. Don't know why though?
      The youth with gurbani knowledge and talent as yours should be encouraged and not shunned. You keep the faith and waheguru's bani in your heart and rest will follow.

      Delete
    3. I had the pleasure of joining the event as an outsider
      The blog is well defined how as an outsider we felt.
      Those orange color fabrics given to all with a certificate frames were never well described by the man wearing black suit right behind the podium
      Also the distributions of them all was also by all male contenders. I did ask this questions right there and later in an email. The reply was satisfactory but much later through an email but the organizers of the event need to know the flaws here.

      Delete
  18. Naureen, MORE POWER TO YOU, Sista !!
    A very well-written blog ! Keep up the good work !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Anonymous,

      Thank you so much for your kind words :) I really do appreciate it!

      Delete
  19. It was so much fun yesterday to hold the banner and show the support without anyone ripping the banners shameful way.
    And no permissions were also needed. ha ha ha
    Had a blast all day yesterday



    Now you should expose all the names right here who ripped the banners and pretend now nothing was done.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Lindsey,

      Thank you so much for your kind words and support. I agree- hopefully these issues can be fixed in future years so we can grow as a Sikh community in Colorado! Removal of banners, especially for young Sikhs, defeats the purpose of the event in my opinion!

      Delete
  20. The problem with these Nagar Kirtans and Sikh Parades in the West is that while we spend money with open heqrts but the management aspect is often overlooked. We need to understand that the non-Sikhs dont know Punjabi so to indulge them in a meningful way (other than just handing out Langar), we need to work on the language barrier too. I'm sure as more and more youngsters get involved they'll understand and work on this issue.
    As far as representation of women is concerned, yes that is a real issue, but I feel the fair sex also needs to step up their participation. The good news is Sikh girls like yourself do come up now and speak their minds, which is essential. My two cents are that their should be a certain obligatory representation for women in Gurdwara committees, this will go a long way to rectify the situation.
    Thanks for this blog.

    WJKK WJKF

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello!

      First of all, I would like to sincerely thank you for taking the time to write and reply to the blog. It is always nice to read comments like these because they encourage youth to step up to the plate, rather than putting blame and shunning them away.

      I couldn't agree with you anymore on all the points you have brought up. For the lack of representation of females in gurudwaras, due to the severity of the issue, I think the implementation of a "quota" like system can be beneficial. Of course, that brings in the question of making sure qualified individuals are in place, and not just having a female for sake of having a female. It's a very complex issue needless to say!

      Once again, thank you for being so supportive of Sikh youth, and females for that matter. :)

      Delete
  21. Searching for some random articles, I found the link to this blog and I must say I'm impressed by a pretty unbiased account of the whole thing.
    I was planning to be there for this event but was out of town, and didn't see many pics, videos or mentions in the media. Well it could be because of the fact that I'm or I was new to Colorado. Anyways I wanted to comment on your observations about the events.
    1. Female Representation: It's just sad that for a religion which started to give equal representation to every human being irrespective of their religion, caste or sex has lagged behind so much in the present day! To put things into perspective, I don't think I've seen women doing kirtan in golden temple either, though I've seen them doing it in local or smaller Gurudwaras. And if someone is saying that women cannot be part of Panj pyaras they are demeaning the message of Guru Nanak who said, “Jin kyun mandaa aakhiey jis jamme rajan” ! For real though, someone who claims to be a Sikh, should open their minds a little and try to learn and change from this age old regressive mentality! What can be done differently to have more female participation?
    As they say change always begins small before becoming a revolution! I hope someone in charge saw these points and will try to make an actual effort to change it.
    2. Engaging with American Neighbours- Wasn’t the whole point of Nagar Kirtan to spread the word or atleast make Americans (and everyone else as well) aware of Sikh culture? I really don’t think setting up donation tables was the right way to go. Had some of that effort went into actually talking to people standing by, it could’ve been made a bigger impact. Again I’m going by your description so can’t really say how good or bad the situation was. Maybe more social media presence or teaming up with something local media groups for future? Also maybe using other non-Sikh Indian groups to spread the word?
    3. Gurudwara Politics: I don’t even want to start about this but how can this be ignored! I remember when I moved from India to Atlanta, and the first time I went to the closest Gurudwara in Atlanta, I felt interrogated about what I do, where do I work, which part of Delhi I am from etc etc. Initially I felt that it was an attempt to get to know more about me, but I quickly realized I was being sized as to how useful I could be to the Gurudwara Committee!
    The next thing I remember was being asked my “full” name as if Singh as a surname isn’t enough. Anyhow next time I went to a different Gurdwara and went through a similar Q&A round. Though realizing I was a “Jatt” (I don’t believe in castes), I was made to feel more welcome(disgusting)! I remember someone saying you shouldn’t go to their Gurudwara and come to this one only. Well that was my last visit to a gurudwara in Atlanta.
    It’s really sad to know that even moving to a different part of the world doesn’t change this mentality of some folks.
    I do remember hanging back to inquire about Sewa. But most of the meetings were focused on how the earlier “Pradhan” or “Secretary Saab” was trying to influence next election! This one elderly Uncle was trying to get some volunteers to get an old industrial freezer which someone was ready to donate to the Gurudwara but no one was interested in that, they had gossiping and bitching to do.
    I’m trying to make a point that if someone like that reaches a little or significant position of influence, they focus their efforts on politics instead of making an impact or change. But the good thing in my opinion is that the next generation is different and they see through this charade. Hopefully more people like you will come into Gurudwara politics and be the change they want to see!
    P.S: I was brought up in a Sikh family, and I’m proud of my Sikh culture and heritage but I am an atheist. And even as an Atheist I can see the positives in my culture and would love to see it grow!

    ReplyDelete